Lisa Boggs

Viewpoint one: Constitutionality of roadblock is outside the scope of Administrative License Suspension hearing.

Sankeralli v. the Department of Drivers’ Services, Judge Schroer held that the constitutionality of the roadblock that lead to the driver’s arrest for driving under the influence (DUI) is outside the scope of an Administrative License Suspension hearing, because the exclusionary rule, the remedy for unconstitutional searches and seizures, does not apply in an administrative […]

Viewpoint one: Constitutionality of roadblock is outside the scope of Administrative License Suspension hearing. Read More

Viewpoint two: Constitutionality of roadblock is within the scope of Administrative License Suspension hearing.

Hamilton v. the Department of Drivers’ Services, Judge Walker held that the state must produce evidence of the constitutionality of a roadblock in order to show that the driver stopped at the roadblock was lawfully arrested, a matter within the scope of the Administrative License Suspension hearing.  This view is not shared by all OSAH

Viewpoint two: Constitutionality of roadblock is within the scope of Administrative License Suspension hearing. Read More

Implied consent notice for deaf drivers must be conveyed by interpreter or in writing.

Where a hearing impaired individual is stopped for driving under the influence (DUI), the arresting officer must arrange for the implied consent warning to be conveyed by a qualified interpreter or in writing.  As the arresting officer failed to provide the implied consent notice in the proper format for a hearing impaired driver, the administrative

Implied consent notice for deaf drivers must be conveyed by interpreter or in writing. Read More

Failure to hold license suspension hearing within thirty days did not harm Petitioner.

Petitioner moved for the rescission of his administrative license suspension on the basis that the Department of Driver Services failed to hold a hearing within thirty days of his request for a hearing and did not issue him a temporary driving permit.  Under the circumstances, Petitioner’s license suspension was stayed as a result of his

Failure to hold license suspension hearing within thirty days did not harm Petitioner. Read More

Concern for family not sufficient to excuse refusal to take breath test.

A driver’s refusal to submit to a breath test following his arrest for DUI was not justified by personal concerns for his family, his confusion regarding the content of the implied consent warning, or the officer’s failure to affirmatively provide him with an opportunity to rescind his refusal. In addition, an original printed slip from

Concern for family not sufficient to excuse refusal to take breath test. Read More

Scroll to Top